You be the Judge and Jury

You are the Judge

In this case you are the Judge. I will provide the absolutely true set of facts in the separate cases will decide innocent or guilty.

The format will be questions and answers directed at me, Barb's husband. Barb has refused to take part in this investigation. Her refusal to take part is not to be construed as guilty. Barb's guilt or innocence is to be determined on the facts of the case.

Opening statement

Barb claims she was a virgin on her wedding night. By definition of virgin, Barb means that no man has inserted his penis in her vagina prior to her wedding night. This investigation is to determine if Barb is telling the truth or if there is enough reasonable doubt to say that Barb's virginity was taken prior to her wedding night.

However on Barb's wedding night, when her new husband's cock entered her vagina, there was no bleeding or breaking of the hymen. When asked about it Barb said she broke her hymen when she played softball.

Legal Question: How old were you when this took place?

Answer: We were both 18 years old. We graduated high school and got engaged right away. We were going to be married that December.

Legal Question: Please describe Barb to us.

Answer: Barb was a very attractive young lady. 5'2", 110 lbs., very toned body, firm B breasts, thin tight waist, nicely rounded ass, very shapely legs and a sexy walk that attracted attention. She always wore here dresses about 2" shorter than the norm. She was a flirt and teaser. She had nice blond hair and pink lipstick that attracted the attention of all red blooded guys.

Legal Question: Where did this take place?

Answer: In a small town in Saskatchewan Canada.

Legal Question: What did Barb tell you about her virginity.

Answer: She was adamant that she was a virgin and she was saving herself for her wedding night.

Legal Question: Did you ever have any reason to doubt her?

Answer: No, because during our courting days, she would never let me come close to putting my penis in her vagina so I assumed she was firm on this point.

Legal Question: Tell us just how far Barb would let you go in your passion play prior to marriage.

Answer: If I was in a particular sexy mood, which was most of the time, I would drive her out into the country and park in a place where we both felt safe and there was no chance of being interrupted. I would slide the seat back and we would kiss up a storm. Once she stared to breath a little heavy my hands would caress her breasts through her blouse. She had very sensitive breasts and nipples. They would harden and I could feel them easily through her blouse and bra. I would undo a button or two and slip my hand in and under her bra. Now her breathing would make a considerable difference. Over the next 15 – 20 minutes I would undo all the buttons on her blouse and undo her bra. Slowly I would remove both. She liked the feeling of freedom and having her breasts caressed. I would kiss and lick the nipples. This drove her crazy. She wore a lot of short skirts and pantyhose. I was never a fan of pantyhose but with short skirts being in style, pantyhose was the norm. I would run my hands up her legs and she would slowly spread her legs so I could rub her pussy through her pantyhose and panties. She liked this. About this time she would be rubbing my cock through my pants. I would slowly hike her skirt up until it was gathered at her waist. I would then slip my hand inside her pantyhose and caress her tight flat belly through her panties. Most times she wore tiny bikini panties that left her belly exposed. She was very sensitive (ticklish) in this area and loved to be caressed. I would slowly work the pantyhose down being careful to leave the panties in place so she would feel secure. I would finally get the pantyhose down to below her knees. I would then have to take a risk and stop kissing and caressing for a moment to take the pantyhose off her feet. If she was excited enough, she would let me take them off, if she wasn't or if I was moving too fast, the pantyhose stayed on just below the knees. Once the pantyhose were off, I was back tickling her stomach and slowly moving down onto her panty covered pubic mound. She would spread her legs a little and I could get a finger or two between her legs and tease the tip of her clit. It would be around this time that I would undo my pants, slide them down and take my cock out. I would slip my fingers under her panties and slowly slide them down being careful not to go too fast. Once they were free of her pussy I would slide them down to her knees. She would let them slip down to her feet and occasionally off completely. As my fingers could more easily find her clit, her level of excitement was climbing and she would orgasm. She would kiss my cock head or suck it for just a minute or two. I would try to reposition so that I lay on top of her and she was always careful to keep my bare cock on her stomach or pubic mound. She would never let me slip my cock between her legs. She would say if I want to put my cock between her legs, her panties have to come back up. I would pull her panties back up then stick my cock between her legs. No pumping with my cock between her legs but it felt great just having it there. When the lust reached a certain point, I would sit up and she would jerk my cock until I went off. We would then clean up, get dressed and head home.

Legal Question: Did Barb like to sexually tease?

Answer: She loved it. Let me give you and example. The two of us were at her place and no one else was home. We were going to go out when she said she wanted to take a bath first. I sat on the couch while she went into the bathroom. I heard the water running and soon I heard her splashing in the water. She called to me. I answered and she said to come wash her back. When I entered the bathroom the shower curtain was pulled and she told me to kneel beside the tub and slip my hand around the plastic curtain. I did so and she put a bar of soap in my hand and guided it to her back. I rubbed the bar of soap all around her back. I tried to sneak around to her breasts but was stopped. I put the soap down and just rubbed her back for quite some time. I then scooped water from down by her butt and rinsed her back. She then asked me to hand her a towel. I did so and watched as she stood behind the plastic screen and wrapped the towel around her body. She slid the curtain aside and stepped out of the tub. She was going into the bedroom and I followed. She sat on the bed and said she couldn't get dressed with me there. I went to the bed, kissed her and laid her down. I laid on top of her as we kissed. After a minute or two I undid the tucked towel and slipped it out from between us. I was fully dressed and she was completely naked. She wrapped her arms around me and held me tight so I couldn't get at her body or my clothes. We rubbed against each other for some time before Barb said she wanted to get dressed. I got up and had a wonderful view of her naked body for a couple seconds until she wrapped the towel around her body again.

Legal Question: If you both lived in the same small town, and spent most of your time together, when do you suppose Barb lost her virginity?

Answer: I had an opportunity to work at a project out of town for three weeks and make some real good money. Since we were getting married in a couple months, the extra money would come in handy so I took the job. It meant that I would be gone for 3 weeks in August.

Legal Question: What makes you think Barb lost her virginity during that 3 weeks?

Answer: During that period of time there was a pipeline contractor working in the area and he had his workers stay in our town. One of the young workers ran into Barb on the street and was taken with her beauty. Barb, being a tease, and from what I hear, the guy was very handsome and quite a hulk. They met every day after that first meeting right up until the contractor moved out of town which happened to be just before I returned to town. After I returned Barb told me about her friend. I asked what they did together. She said they would sit on the couch and watch tv. I asked how far they went. She said he put his arm around her, held her hand and kissed her. I asked if they went any further. She said no.

Legal Question: In your opinion, do you think she is being truthful?

Answer: No, anytime Barb and I would sit and watch tv, the holding hands and kissing would soon progress to caressing and removal of clothing. It wouldn't take much and Barb would be breathing hard and quite sexually excited so I find it difficult to believe that with this new guy, all she did was hold hands and a little kissing. A new guy would be exciting and the sexual energy would be greater so that makes her story more unlikely.

Legal Question: What makes you think she lost it to him and not some other local fellow?

Answer: Not sure however, after I returned this fellow kept phoning Barb about once a week for a couple months. If all a fellow did was kiss a pretty girl in a town he was passing through, I don't think he would be caught up enough to phone every week for several months? I believe in order for a relationship to develop to that level of bond in such a short time, the level of bonding would need to be quite intense, such as full vaginal penetration.

Legal Question: Understanding this answer will not be fact only your opinion, what do you think happened?

Answer: If sitting on the couch watching tv is so prominent in Barb's mind, I think their sexual petting progressed from kissing to caressing. The excitement of a new partner would have had Barb really excited. Removing clothing is no unusual so I am sure that Barb's breasts were exposed and this guy had Barb very excited with his caresses. I know that Barb is ok with removing her skirt or having it up around her waist so I have no doubt that happened. Would she let him put his hand in her panties and remove them? Yes, I know that if she is excited enough, this has never been a problem. At times like this my pants and underwear are either at my feet or off completely so his likely were down or off. Barb is usually playing with my cock and maybe kissing and sucking it a little. If she would do it with me, I have every reason to believe she would do it with this exciting new boyfriend. She would let me lay on top of her and rub my bare cock on her stomach and pubic bone so I am sure she would let him do that also. This is the point where I could go no further because if she spread her legs and allowed the cock between her legs, penetration is nearly impossible to prevent. In the situation of the new exciting boyfriend who is leaving in a couple days, his need to suceed is heightened by knowing it is now or never. Barb likely feels the same sense of now or never. She doesn't have to agree to the penetration. All she has to do is not say no so she likely just spread her legs slightly and then let nature take its course. He would slip his cock between her legs. Her pussy by this time would be very wet and slippery. His cock would slip effortlessly down, splitting her lips and poised to enter her vagina. I believe he would enter her vagina and upon feeling the resistance apply the necessary pressure to complete the penetration. Yes, I know Barb would feel the pain however the emotional bonding through the giving of her virginity would account for her continued interest in him even after he is gone from town.

Legal Question: Describe your wedding night for us?

Answer: Barb came out of the bathroom wearing a tiny black negligee. She got into bed and we kissed, caressed and after some foreplay she spread her legs. I positioned myself between her legs. My cock rubbed up against her pussy. I slowly pushed and all 6 inches of it slipped completely into her vagina effortlessly. Yes, it was tight and she was slightly uncomfortable. I don't know if the "uncomfortable" was because of no hymen or nervous wedding night. I pumped into her vagina until we both cum and then we lay there in each other's arms with my cock in her vigina. When we cleaned up a short while later there was no blood. I asked why and Barb said she broke her hymen playing softball. That has been her story ever since.

Defense Legal question: Did Barb ever cheat on you with other boys?

Answer: Not that I know of. There were other boyfriends before me.

Defense Legal question: What did Barb tell you she did with this fellow?

Answer: Barb said she was snuggling on the couch. She said he had his arm around her and they kissed.

Defense Legal question: Since you have no indication that Barb cheated before and she is honest enough to tell you what she did, on what grounds do you not believe her?

Answer: I know any red-blooded young guy is going to try to get as much as he can. I know he would not have stopped at just his arm around her and kissing. I also know how quickly Barb gets sexually excited when the passionate kissing starts. I also know Barb had no problem letting the passion go much further than kissing. In general, she was a tease and liked to use her body to tease guys. I just don't believe she would have put the brakes on at just kissing. I also witnessed what appeared to be a bonding of some sort as she was excited when he called over the next couple months.

There you have it. Was Barb being truthful in saving her virginity for her husband but lost it on the softball field? Was her husbands cock the first one to penetrate her vigina? Or did she give in to passion and allow her new exciting boyfriend spread her legs and penetrate her vagina?

We have presented the facts as we know them. Now you as Judge need to make a decision.