My Eyes Are Closed

====================================

All Characters are 18 years or older.

This story contains elements of voyeurism and, not to bury the lead, some group sex and technical non-consent.

Thanks to Ante-Matter for his consistently fantastic editing.

====================================

"You do get that your brother is pretty cute, right?"

Waking up to that statement was unexpected, but considering I had fallen asleep in the basement lying on a couch in front of a muted TV, I wasn't really expecting anything at all.

My older sister was having her 'Annual Sleepover.' Years earlier that had meant over a dozen girls all cramming themselves into my parents house, making a complete mess and devouring snacks like a plague of locusts. I went through phases in how I reacted to this yearly event, mostly depending on my age and level of hormones. When I was eight, I hated it and hid in my room the entire weekend. By the time I was fourteen, I was fascinated by all the pyjama clad girls and my parents realized it, banishing me to my room instead of my self-imposed exile. Now I was eighteen, and my sister's social circle had thinned as her friends went to college or moved away. Over a dozen had diminished to five last year, and this year Nancy had only managed to finagle two of her best friends over.

That was probably a good thing, since our parents had gone off on a two week cruise five days earlier. I could only imagine what the house would have looked like if she'd had one of her old fashioned ragers like back in high school.

As the sheer numbers had dwindled the past couple years, I'd finally been allowed to hang around the house during the party, and since our parents weren't around at all I had declared myself master of the basement, and thereby the entertainment centre, leaving Nancy, Erin and Amanda the run of the living room upstairs, along with the kitchen.

I'd played video games for a few hours, stripped down to a t-shirt and boxers despite the company in the house. Erin and Amanda had both seen me naked the year before when, on a joint family camping trip, I had been dared to streak through the campgrounds at night. They, and my sister, were supposed to do it after I had made sure it was safe, but instead they had ambushed me at the finish line with a polaroid camera, laughing their heads off and waking up half the camp.

At some point I must have fallen asleep, and now their voices were close by. I kept my breathing regular and forced myself not to smile, preparing to jump up and scare them as soon as they got close enough. They kept talking across the room, however, and I opened my eyes just enough to look through my lashes sideways at them.

"Yeah, I know," my sister responded, "Not like I can do anything about it though."

Erin snorted, clapping her hands over her mouth to stop from laughing out loud and waking me up. She had a broad, angular face with bright green eyes and a ready smile, and her auburn hair was thick and full, but we all knew her best asset was her slim body. She ate like a pig, but somehow she always managed to stay thin and trim, her cute little butt and tits usually hugged by form-fitting yoga pants and clingy shirts that showed off her flat tummy.

"Still, it's a waste to leave him here like this. So vulnerable, just waiting to get pranked." That was clearly Amanda, just out of my field of view. Where Nancy was a tall and statuesque blonde, like the rest of our family, Amanda was short, curvy and a huge tease. She had the ass of a pornstar and she used it frequently to play with my head, bumping against me 'by accident' or brushing way closer than necessary to get by in a small area. She was also the instigator of their little group, and I was pretty sure she was the one that had brought the polaroid camera that time at camp.

My sister grinned and nodded, "I think you're right, but what should we do to him? I do need to live with him without my parents around for another week, it can't be too mean."

"Something with a delayed reaction?" Erin suggested. "Maybe something he won't even know about until it's too late for revenge."

"Or maybe," I could practically hear the cogs working amongst the brain trust as Amanda filled in, "We do something he won't even want to take revenge for. He'll just know he missed out on something great."

The three girls were suddenly whispering, probably a natural reaction to the fact that they were conspiring to do something. Finally, Nancy broke off, "Alright, I'll go get the camera. Don't wake him up!"

As my sister bounded up the stairs her two friends quietly 'snuck' over to me, giggling to themselves and gesturing oddly. It would have almost been worth it to just scare the two of them, but I wanted the catch all three in the act now so I kept breathing regularly and kept myself from moving. Erin was wearing the same pyjama outfit as my sister, fleece pants riding low and an old tank top. Amanda, on the other hand, was wearing a flannel nightie that looked more like a shirt. Both girls knelt on the floor beside me and tried to check to see if I was awake. There was a lot of hand waving and silly faces and it took all of my concentration not to flinch or blink my mostly-closed eyes.

Nancy finally came back down the stairs, her digital camera in hand, and quietly tiptoed over. "Ok," she whispered, powering it on, "What are we gonna do?"

Amanda grinned, "Let's moon him, take a picture of our butts right in his face."

Erin and Nancy snickered, following Amanda's lead. Nancy stood at the opposite end of the couch and pointed the camera at me, and I heard rustling behind me. Nancy covered her mouth, trying not to laugh, and snapped a couple of pictures. Suddenly a shadow loomed over my head and I could see the pale flesh of someone's butt out of the corner of my eye. Click, click, went the camera.

"Ok," I heard Amanda whisper from behind me as the barely seen butt moved away. "Your turn Nancy."

My sister made a face. "I dunno, that feels kinda weird," she whispered.

"Oh come on," Erin whispered back, "It's just your butt and thong. Plus, we all need to do it or else one of us could use it against the others."

Amanda agreed, but Nancy snorted, "Yeah, because we would definitely do that to each other."

"Come on," Amanda said a little louder, "Sister solidarity or whatever. Just do it."

Nancy rolled her eyes. "Fine."

The girls all switched places and I lost sight of Nancy as she moved behind my head. Amanda and Erin came into view, however, and I found out Erin had dropped her fleece pants and was clad in just her old pink tank top and a tiny blue thong. I swear I must have flinched, but none of them noticed.

The two friends stood at the end of the couch, jockeying for position, as Nancy did something behind me. Amanda had the camera and lifted it up above her head to get a good angle, lifting her nightie in the process until I had a clear view of her own fabric-covered mound. It might have been a shadow, but I could have sworn she had a firm camel toe going on, maybe even a little wet spot.

Click, click, click. The camera snapped in quick succession, Erin and Amanda laughing quietly at whatever Nancy was doing behind my head. Suddenly I felt rather than saw something get really close to the top of my head, and Erin gasped. Amanda on the other hand was grinning wickedly and I knew my sister had just pushed the envelope.

The presence disappeared from above my head and Nancy came into view, rushing over to see the pictures. She'd followed Erin's example, and was now clad in a pale green thong that gave me a great view of her butt. I'm not ashamed to admit that I knew she had a nice ass. I'd seen her in enough bikinis and she'd mooned me from across a room while being silly enough times that I was fully aware of what other guys called her 'bubble butt.' I thought it was more of a peach-butt, right down to the dimples on her lower back.

Either way, I was getting an eyeful as the girls giggled, scrolling through the pictures on the camera. They got to the last one and Nancy made a face, part proud and part anxious, while Erin blew out a breath through pursed lips. "I can't believe you did that," Erin said.

What did she do!?! I was screaming in my head, but none of them answered my silent question.

Amanda, on the other hand, still had the wicked smile. "Ok, let's up the anty, make him really wish he was awake." She grabbed Erin's hand and pulled her over towards my head. Amanda disappeared behind me, but Erin knelt on the floor beside me, putting her little apple-sized tits right next to my face. I could tell from here she wasn't wearing a bra, her nipples making little bumps in the tank top she was wearing and the jiggle as she moved loose and free.

"What are we-!" Erin started to ask, but something happened and I heard her inhale sharply through her nose. Click, click, click.

"You two are so bad," my sister whispered, coming around the end of the couch and getting the camera closer. I didn't know where to look, at the barely covered breasts in my peripheral vision or at my sisters thong-covered pussy. The light green fabric was pulled tight and taught, like the underwear was a size too small for her, and this time I was sure I was seeing camel toe.

A motion in Erin's direction caught my attention and when my eyes slid back over I realized Amanda had lifted up Erin's shirt, revealing her tits. Boobs! My head screamed at me, but I had to lay still and couldn't get a better look. Then I heard the light smacking sound and my sister moved in a bit closer, looming over me. Click, click, click. Erin and Amanda were making out over my head, and at least Erin had her tits out for it. Knowing Amanda, she'd probably gotten hers out first to make sure Erin couldn't complain.

The noises finally stopped and Erin slipped her shirt back down. The two girls stood and walked to my sister, standing right next to my head as they looked at the camera. Three thongs were staring back at me. My sister's in green, Erin's in blue and Amanda's in white with little red polkadots. All three had their thongs wedged tightly, showing off their pouty lips, and now I was certain Amanda had a little wet spot. I was also getting a partial view of her amazing tits, because while the camera and all three girls hands were in the way, Amanda had undone the front buttons of her nightie all the way and was standing with them on full display. From what I could tell, she barely had any sag going on and her nipples were a dark pink, standing up at attention.

"Ok," Nancy said when they had finished looking through the newest pictures, "I guess you guys want me to do that too?"

"Well, I mean I'll make out with you if you really want," Amanda said flippantly, "But you don't have to if you just dangle your tits right in his face."

Nancy shrugged, "That's better I guess."

Erin was grinning now too, which made me worried because Erin was always the quietest of their group. She and Amanda moved back to the other end of the couch as Nancy got behind my head. I was safe for now at least, able to stare at Amanda's bare tits without worrying about looking too much at my sister.

Or at least I thought so until I suddenly had my vision blocked by two white globes. Not quite completely white though, right on the downward most points I could make out a light pink and I could feel Nancy's nipple brushing against either cheek.

My immediate desire was to open my mouth and try and gobble up one of those nipples, but I didn't. All three girls were laughing quietly now and I had to wonder how they thought I wouldn't wake up. I stayed still, however, wondering how far this whole thing was going to go. It was getting harder and harder to remain still, and I could already feel my dick starting to react from the visual stimulation.

Suddenly the tits moved away and I could see Amanda and Erin again, not that the sight helped any. Nancy walked back into view and this time I know I blinked several times, but none of the girls were watching. Nancy had taken off her shirt entirely and was standing there in just her thong. Where Amanda's tits were an overflowing handful, my sister's by pure size ratio were even bigger. She was almost as tall as me, and I was in the six foot four range, so it made sense that even though her tits looked natural for her athletic body, they were just plain bigger. They were tear-drop shaped, capped by a pair of light pink nipples that stood out proudly.

The three girls giggled over the pictures of my sister, then even through my half closed lids I could see Amanda's eyes flash as she got another idea. "Ok, one more thing then we're done. But you both have to promise to do it too."

"There's not much more to do without waking him up," my sister said, "I'm in."

Erin nodded her agreement, and Amanda licked her lips before bending over and shucking off her thong altogether. Standing there, her body framed by the wide open flannel shirt, she was stunning. She had a little landing strip of pubic hair above her mound and I could see her pussy lips standing out prominently. She moved out of my field of vision, the two girls following her with their eyes questioningly, then the cushions on either side of my head depressed. My vision was again blocked, but this time I was getting more than an eyeful of my sisters underboob. Amanda had straddled my head and had dropped her pussy to within inches of my face, shaking with laughter.

"Oh my god, Amanda!" My sister hissed quietly, but Erin was holding her sides laughing quietly, tears leaking from her face.

"What?" I heard above me somewhere, "He missed out on allll this. Take the pictures, I can't hold this position forever. And besides, you were the one who spread your butt while you were mooning him."

Nancy what now? I thought, but didn't have much brain power to spend on the thought, I was too busy concentrating on the quivering pussy above me. She was wet, and I could smell the arousal coming off of her and all I wanted to do was reach up, wrap my hands around my sister's best friend and pull her down onto my face. But then the moment was over, and the pussy disappeared, and I was left looking surreptitiously at Erin and my sister, who had been snapping pictures despite her outburst.

"Ok," Amanda said as she rounded the couch again, not bothering to pick up here thong, "Your turn Erin."

The tiny girl looked shocked for a second, like she hadn't expected to be next. "Uh, alright I guess. Can I leave my shirt on?"

"Yeah, that's fine," Nancy said quickly, "The point is that your so close he could have tasted you." All three girls laughed quietly and Erin rounded my head before taking off her thong, but fairly quickly legs were straddling my head again and another pussy swung down into view. Where Amanda had prominent lips, Erin's were puffy and stubby, the inner lips sticking out like a little tongue. Again, I could smell the arousal emanating, and I felt like I could almost feel heat coming off of her. Click, click, click, went the camera until she finally dismounted.

I heard my sister snort, and she was pointing at me. "Look what you did to my innocent brother!" The way I was laying, I could see that despite my best efforts, I was indeed now sporting a chub, tenting my boxers slightly.

"Alright," Amanda said quietly, "Last one I guess." Erin, still naked from the waist down and sporting a clean shaven pussy, and Amanda both looked to my sister. She shrugged and pushed down her own thong, revealing that she was shaven clean as well.

"All for one, or whatever."

She disappeared and I could feel myself tensing. I was about to stare my sister's pussy in the face and I wasn't feeling ashamed at all. I was excited. I had always loved my older sister, how free she was with her emotions and how goofy she liked to be. I couldn't help the fact that she was also gorgeous, her face like an elongated heart and her light brown eyes full of mischief. I loved and lusted after my sister, and I wasn't afraid to admit that as I felt the cushions on either side of my head press down.

Here it comes, I thought, and I saw the shadow moving down, and then I was completely covered in wet, fleshy darkness.

"Oh shit!" I heard above me, and the darkness immediately lifted over my line of sight. Amanda was on the ground laughing silently, banging a fist on the carpet, while Erin looked on open-mouthed.

Amanda, struggling to control her volume, wheezed, "I can't believe that just happened!"

"I slipped!" I heard my sister retort, and I clued in that I'd just gotten a face full of pussy and ass. I had the urge to lick my lips to see if I could taste anything, but Erin was still staring at where my sister's downstairs had accidentally met my upstairs. "Come on, just take the picture already, that was totally embarrassing."

Just as the shadow started moving down into my view again, I wondered if that sounded as much like a lie to the other girls as it had to me. Then I was looking my sister right in the orifice.

Unlike the other two girls, who were a little bit tanned or sun-kissed, Nancy is a pale girl, and apparently the parts of her that never see the sun might as well be bleached white. Her pussy was a dull pink, obviously flushed from the stimulation, but the rest of the skin I could see was as white as porcelain. Click, click, click, went the camera and I tried to memorize what I was seeing. Who knew, I might have had a chance at Amanda or Erin after this, but I was never going to see Nancy's pussy again.

"Oh my god, Nancy, look!" I could feel Nancy's weight shift above me, and heard her gasp. Then I realized I was definitely hard enough that I was poking through my boxers and they were all staring at my dick. Not that fair wasn't fair, but I was just waiting for the scream and them all to run away.

"Now that is hot," Amanda said.

Erin seemed to take in a deep breath before replying, "Yep."

Nancy dismounted me and came around, kneeling next to my abdomen, her tits almost resting on my stomach and giving me a view of all three girls in their states of undress. "Ok, I admit it, even if he is my brother. That is a pretty dick."

I'd never thought of my ol' johnson as 'pretty' before, but with three girls ogling it and making comments I wasn't about to go soft again any time soon.

Amanda shoved Erin over towards my sister, "Go on, pretend to suck it. This is even better than the other stuff."

"What?" Erin and Nancy said at the same time.

"Just open your mouth and breathe on it," Amanda explained, "You don't need to actually suck it, just make it look like you're going to."

Nancy rolled her eyes, but Erin seemed to catch on and, grinning like a fiend, she knelt down beside my sister and opened her mouth wide, posing with my dick hovering between her pretty lips. I could feel her hot breath caressing me and I struggled to keep still, at this point there was no way they wouldn't notice even a twitch. Click, click, click.

Erin backed her head off and away, avoiding touching me, then suddenly leaned forward and gave the side of my head a kiss. Click.

Nancy whispered an aggravated, "Hey, no touching!" and pushed her friend lightly.

"What?" Erin responded, "You said it first, it's a pretty dick."

Nancy turned to Amanda, who was still holding the camera. "I guess you want me to do the same thing, don't you?" Amanda just grinned and nodded, raising the camera to her face. Nancy rolled her eyes and shifted over, putting her face right next to my dick and giving the camera a silly look. Click. Then she pretended to be about to bite it. Click. Then she took up the same hovering position as Erin had, her mouth over my cock but not touching, the difference was that her much larger breasts were hanging, rubbing up against the side of my leg and I could feel Nancy's nipples hardening as they scraped back and forth. Click, click.