Gang-Banging My Brothers as a Dare

All characters in this story are over the age of 18.

*****

Finally, spent and exhausted, I fall back on the bed, I'm hot, sweaty, sticky and covered in cum, I feel as though I've been fucking for hours, then I look at my watch and realise I've been fucking for hours, four hours straight. I've just had my first gang-bang.

My pussy is raw and swollen, my jaw aches, my throat is sore, my boobs and nipples are tender from the pawing and licking and sucking they have gone through, the only part of me that doesn't hurt is my bum and that has been bitten and slapped a few time, but I had warned them if anyone tried to fuck me there I would cut off all their dicks and make them eat them. They knew I meant it, nothing else was off limits though.

I've pulled a train, been spit roasted, swapped off on, been double teamed, sucked more cock and swallowed more cum than I have ever done before, and I've loved every second of it, and what has made it even more exciting for me is the fact that the four lucky guys who've had the pleasure and privilege of fucking me are my four brothers.

Yes, my first gang-bang was an incestuous one. But let me tell you how things happened.

My family has always been close and very open about things, and pretty wild as well. I'm the middle of five kids and the only girl. I've got two older brothers, John 22, Mark 20, then me, and then the twins who are younger both just turned eighteen, Matt and Luke, these two are the bane of my life always teasing and tormenting me. I'm Mary aged nineteen. If you've picked up on the names, we come from a good Catholic background. John, Mark and I were planned apparently, but the twins were a bit of a mistake. To my mind not a good one either.

We've always been open with everything but tease and challenge each other all the time, especially the twins with me, they are always making sexual innuendoes to and about me, but to be fair I always give as good as I take. And I am no innocent blushing virgin either.

We were having a truth or dare game and it was getting pretty intense, I was being grilled about my sex life, nothing new there then. They want to get me to refuse to answer a question so I have to do a dare. Probably strip down to my bra and panties and act as a waitress for them, that seems to be their favourite punishment for me. The thing is all four of them know I never, ever, refuse a dare, a trait that has got me in trouble a couple of times in the past.

"Done oral?"

"Plenty of times."

"Swallow?"

"Every time, is there any other way!"

"Done a girl?" said with a snigger from Luke.

"Yes, more than one and definitely more then you have," I shot back at him raising a laugh from everyone else. "Why, do you want to know what it's like?" I teased him, not the best idea in a truth or dare game I should have realised.

Things continued on like this, the questions getting more and more intimate. Now don't get this wrong it wasn't just me who was being grilled we all had to answer a question in turn, and I was asking some pretty intense and downright perverted questions of my brothers, hell there are four of them to one of me, so obviously I was getting more questions to answer than them.

Then came the question that changed everything.

"Ever been with a family member?"

No answer.

"Mary, have you ever been with a family member?"

No answer.

"Mary, answer or it's a dare."

"What do you mean a family member, how close a family member."

"Anyone that's related to you, cousin, uncle, aunt, you know a family member."

I take my time before I answer as I know I will be betraying a sacred trust, then looking at them defiantly answer, "Siobhan, once about three years ago. Happy now?"

"Cousin Siobhan, wow she's hot even for her age."

"No, not cousin Siobhan. Aunt Siobhan."

Aunt Siobhan is our mums' much younger sister, about twelve years younger, so she is a lot nearer my age than mums, in fact, we were nearly at school together in different years of course.

"Wow, she's even hotter," that is true Siobhan is hot and sexy, a tall redhead with a dancers body. Even though I'm not fully into girls I get wet thinking of her and the couple of times we got together when I seduced her, but that is a different story.

"What was it like?"

"That's not a fair question, not fair to Siobhan."

"OK, but did you enjoy it?"

"What do you think? Of course, I did."

"Is she the only one?"

"Only one what, girl or family member?" That was something I shouldn't have brought up, it just gave them another opening to probe.

"Both."

"Family yes, girl no."

"How many girls have you done?" this from John, who normally stays out of these sessions, so that shocks me a bit.

Getting bolder now, if they thought they could shock and embarrass me then they were wrong, or so I thought.

"Three."

"Three, are you a lezzie?"

"No! and you know it. For fuck's sake I went to an all-girls school, what do you think I would do, play with myself and fuck my teachers?" Then a sly smile covers my face, as I'd done both of those things many times over. The guys pick up on this and so begins another intense round of questioning, it appears I am now the subject of interrogation, all thoughts of questions to other people have been forgotten, and the questions are getting more and more intrusive, eventually, I know I am going to refuse to answer.

"Ever done a three-way?"

"Yes, and before you ask both, as two girls and one man and the other way. Happy now."

"Which did you prefer, two girls or two men?"

"Both the same, I liked both of them?"

"Ever done a gang-bang?"

"I'm not answering that, anyway what do you mean gang-bang, how many?"

"More than two guys and you."

"In that case no. And that's all the questions I'm answering," I said trying to end this before things get out of hand but I have a feeling that that point had already passed.

"Do you want to?"

No answer.

"Mary, answer or it's dare time."

No answer from me.

"Mary, one last time, do you want to do a gang-bang, have you fantasied about a gang-bang?"

Something was wrong here, the guys were pressing too hard on this subject, I had to kill it off now.

"Maybe, and that's the end no more questions, what are you lot perverts?"

"Given the chance," leered Luke. Looking at me and rubbing his groin.

"I dare you to have a gang-bang. Fuck four guys at once." John shocked me at this suggestion coming from him, and the look I gave him could have killed, he'd used the dare word, now I was trapped.

"No way, never happening."

"Thought you were the "queen of the dares", never refuse a dare."

"That's not fair and you know it," I shot back at them.

"Anyway, how could we tell if she did, she could say she had and we'd never know the difference," said Mark.

"We could watch," from Luke.

"Nobody would want to get involved with that," said John.

"Video it," typically came from Matt.

"Not that I'm going to indulge you perverts by doing a gang-bang, but I would definitely not video it for you. You are just a bunch of perverts." Why I hadn't walked out I don't know, but something was stirring in me. I did fancy a gang-bang I had been thinking about how to go about it which guys I could get involved but there was no way these perverts were going to know about it.

Then John of all people changed everything with his next words.

"You could take us on, there's four of us."

The room was silent for a shocked second even Luke and Matt were silent at the implication.

"John, what did you just say?" I asked as I couldn't believe my own ears.

"You gang-bang us, keeps everything within the family, nobody else would know and we would get the proof of you doing a gang-bang."

"No fucking way am I gang-banging you four. That's incest, for one thing, that is one step too far. Even for me," I shouted at John.

"No it's not, you've already admitted to incest with Siobhan," said Mark.

"That's different and you know it," I retorted in rage.

"No, it's not."

"Yes it is and you know it, now I'm finished here, bye lads."

As I stood up to leave John uttered the fateful phrase.

"OK "queen of the dares" I dare you to have sex with us, all of us."

I looked at him in shock and then at all of their faces, they were all more than keen, they wanted it and they knew I had never, ever, refused a dare.

"No way."

"Looks like you're going to lose your record then," taunted John of all people. "Mary never turns down a dare."

Looking at them I knew they were serious, I had one hell of a decision to make, end this here and now or do the unthinkable, keep my crown by gang-banging my four brothers.

I sat down, and they knew they had won. The idea of a gang-bang definitely appealed to me, and the idea that it would be an incestuous one only added some spice. I just didn't want them to know I was keen and ready to do it.

I knew I had been trying my hardest to avoid the dare, but I've always been pretty wild and adventurous and as they had pointed out I had had an incestuous relationship before, they just didn't know for how long. They thought it was a one-off time, but in fact, Siobhan and I had been lovers for an intense twelve month period. It was her and her husband who I had had my first three-way with.

"You mean it don't you? You all want to have sex with me, your sister."

"Of course, for my part both individually or as part of a group, hell Mary you are a sexy girl."

Stunned at this admission I took my time thinking. This would be a massive step. Could I do it, have sex with my brothers, not one, but all four and at once, as a gang-bang? My mind was whirling as differing thoughts rushed through it.

The gang-bang idea I was fairly cool about, but the incest side with them was one hell of a step. Looking on it dispassionately I would be getting fucked and fucked hard by them, they would be rough with me, I knew that. They wouldn't be gentle, I knew they would fuck me hard, as hard as they could. Could I handle the physical side? I was fairly sure that I could. I probably wanted it, I had a desire to be fucked really hard and have no or little control in it. Now that did turn me on.

But Catholic guilt assailed me at the idea of sex with them, moral convention and mores pulled at me. Incest is so forbidden, I, no we, would burn in hell if we went down that path, but hadn't I already burnt that bridge, both with Siobhan and with other girls as well, that was a sin as well. But full-on incest with them?

Then I realised I was wet at the idea, God I had got myself turned on by the idea. Also, John and Mark were both pretty cool guys, who if they weren't my brothers I'd have been happy to have sex with at any time they asked.

"OK, you perverts, I am the "queen of the dares" and you are not taking that away from me, so yes I'll do it. I'll fuck all of you in a gang-bang. Now, are you happy. That's if you've all got the balls to do it."

The shocked silence in the room was even more intense and lasted longer than when John had suggested the dare in the first place. They couldn't believe that I had agreed.

...

Having agreed to the gang-bang and having set a date, I turned up at John's house as this is where we had agreed that the "party" would take place. As I expected all the guys were there when I arrived. There was a look of eagerness on all of their faces, their tongues were almost lolling out in anticipation, they were hot for it.

I got a round of appreciation at the sexy way I looked and had dressed. A short, black leather mini skirt and denim blouse opened halfway down, my perky 34C boobs clearly in view for the boys.

I gave a quick spin and pirouette and danced away from the grasping hands of my eager brothers, yes we were going to have sex as a family, they were going to gang-bang me, but only when I was ready, no free gropes for them, especially the twins. I could tell from the look on their faces they were lustful and eager, the definitely wanted me. This could be better than I expected.

"Calm down boys, plenty of time, don't get too eager," I laughed at them. "Right off you go and get a shower, I want you all clean, and make sure you wash your cocks, dirty cock no blow job," I teased them.

That was when it sank in for them, I wasn't backing out! And they knew I was going to make it as good as I could.

As the guys disappeared I went into Johns bedroom and stripped off until I was naked, I wasn't going to give them the extra thrill of me stripping for them. When they all came into the room they were equally disappointed and delighted, delighted at the fact that I was naked, disappointed as they didn't get to see me get naked, I knew they had wanted a strip show from me as a prelude.

I told them to line up next to each other oldest on the left youngest on the right, this caused some fun between the twins until they got things sorted out.

"Inspection time," I told them as I knelt in front of them all and first took Johns already stiff cock in my hand stroking it, pulling the foreskin fully back then without warning any of them, sucked it long and deep into my mouth. John tasted nice, clean but slightly salty, a nice sized cock to get my mouth around as an appetiser, both for him and me. I sucked on John for a few minutes, playing with his balls with my hands, I only used my mouth and lips on his cock. Letting all of them see that I was deep throating him from the off. If they wanted a gang-bang then they were going to get an epic gang-bang.

Finishing with John, without stopping I switched to Mark and did the same to him, long slow deep sucking of his thicker but shorter cock into my eager mouth. Mark tried to get hold of my head and pull me onto him but I slapped his hands away, getting the message that he might mess things up for all of them he eased off and I then allowed him to face fuck me but at my own pace.

The twins could hardly wait for their turns but wait they had to, and they would have to wait when the main course was served as well. They had instigated this but that didn't mean that they were getting first goes at anything.

When it was time for the twins I didn't give them as long as their older brothers, but as a surprise switched off between them a couple of time, at one time trying to get both their cocks into my mouth, but they kept pulling away at that sort of action. Wimps, their older sister wanted to suck both their cocks at the same time and they backed out. I was disappointed in them.

Now for some sex, and by now, I was ready. Although I had initially been reluctant and was only doing this as a dare, the more I had thought about it during the time since agreeing and today, the more excited I had become. If I'd still been wearing panties they would have been soaked my pussy was that wet. I'm surprised they couldn't smell the desire coming off me.

The gang-bang side of it, I was looking forward to a good fucking session, not the incest side, that still worried me in some ways, but in others, the sinfulness of it, the taboo, the breaking of conventions and moral codes was also having an effect on me. If I'm honest if Mark had ever asked me on his own I would probably have said yes to him at any time in the last few years. God, I am a slut.

"OK guys, time to fuck, biggest first." Matt made a move to grab me, but I danced away from him saying, "biggest first."

"I am the biggest," he replied.

"No Matt, you're the tallest, John, is the biggest." Suddenly they all realised what I meant as John definitely had the biggest cock of them all, he smiled in acknowledgement.

I got up off my knees and dropped on my back on the bed beckoning John to join me, even before he had a chance to grasp my legs and hold them I had spread them wide giving him a view of my exposed pussy, he could see how wet it already was.

John got on top of me and slid his nice sized, seven-inch-long cock into me without any problems, then took up a quick rhythm of pushing in and out. Instantly I responded to his pace and matched his thrusts by pushing back hard at him, and raising my hips to help him hit my g spot. We fucked well as a pair my eldest brother and me, we had struck up a pleasing mutual rhythm but it was fucking, there was no semblance of making love, it was sex pure and simple Well not so pure!

John kept up a constant and steady pumping of his nice hard dick into me for about ten minutes gradually increasing the intensity of his thrusts and his pace, cock splitting my wet pussy time and time and again as I climbed to an orgasm, just as I was getting there Johns body went stiff he plunged his dick into me as far as it would go and shot his load of hot cum deep into my pussy, coating the back and sides. I had just started to get into the rhythm of things and was building to an orgasm when John climaxed and finished, breaking my flow.

The second he pulled out, which wasn't long after cumming, Mark took up his place and started a frantic ploughing into me, fucking me a lot harder and faster than John had. His dick was thrusting in and out of me, but he was only pulling halfway out, so I wasn't getting a full feeling of how good his cock could be. The nice thing though was he had taken hold of my ankles and used them to push my legs high and back, knees pushed up against my ears, this was opening my pussy for him and allowing him to access me from a different angle. I was enjoying this. Again Mark lasted about ten minutes before unleashing his load deep into my pussy, holding himself hard against my clit as his cum flooded into me. He had been pawing at my tits all the time he had been fucking me and by now my nipples had become hard and sensitive. But again I hadn't cum.

Luke quickly jumped in to take Mark's place and as he slid his cock into me Matt tried to get his dick into my mouth. Slapping it away and squeezing his balls hard enough to hurt him I said, "No, first time, it's one on one, each of you taking your turn, one on one with me, after that, anything goes. Now just wait your turn." Matt looked upset but still eager and I wondered if I would regret what I had just said later.

Luke didn't mess about, he was young, horny and eager, his cock hammered hard into me, slamming away, going hard and fast, fucking my cunt like there was no tomorrow. Pounding hard and deep into my slippery cunt he had no finesse, he just wanted to fuck me as hard and as fast as he could, to get off as quickly as he could, that was OK by me as the energy of his pumping into me had again started to bring me back up to an approaching climax.

"Mary, oh Mary, I'm cumming," he shouted as his body spasmed and his pounding and thrusting into me became more and more uncoordinated

"OH, I'm cumming, I'm gonna cum in you."

With that another fresh lot of cum flooded my welcoming pussy, coating it even more than it already was, I now had three lots of my brothers cum, mixing and mingling in me. But again, just as I was getting into the flow of things my impending orgasm was stopped by the ending of my brother.

Matt eager to seize his chance, and finally get to fuck his sister, a sister he has lusted after for a while now, pulled Luke off me as soon as he shouted out his climax, causing Luke's cock to dribble over me as it exited my pussy. Not bothered about the mess, Matt got hold of his cock, pointed it at my now well used but still accepting pussy and drove in as hard as he could, slamming me up the bed with his forceful efforts. His lust and eagerness showing in his eagerness, he'd wanted me for ages and hadn't bothered to hide the fact. Matt didn't last long at all, cumming in about two minutes, much to his shame and brothers amusement.

After Matt had finished and I had fucked all four of them one after another, my cunt was filled with cum and was feeling well used, but I wasn't finished yet. And I realised one thing, I had fucked all four of them to a climax but I hadn't cum myself, every time I had got close the guy had cum before I could hit my own climax. Typical of my brothers. Matt said, "Are you going to clean up now."